

Independence and correlation by Seb Wills
Definitions:
y_1 and y_2 are uncorrelated means E{y_1 y_2}  E{y_1}E{y_2} = 0
y_1 and y_2 are independent means p(y_1,y_2) = p_1(y_1) p_2(y_2), i.e.
the joint pdf is factorisable. (Intuitively, this means that learning the
value of one of the variables doesn't tell you anything about the value of
the other).
Fact:
Independence implies uncorrelatedness, but the reverse is not true.
Proof that two random variables can be uncorrelated but not independent:
(based on Aapo Hyvarinen's paper "Independent Component Analysis: A
Tutorial", at
http://www.cis.hut.fi/aapo/papers/IJCNN99_tutorialweb/node7.html)
It is easy to show that for any independent variables y_1 and y_2,
E{h_1(y_1) h_2(y_2)} = E{h_1(y_1)} E{h_2(y_2)} for any functions h_1 and h_2
(property M)
where E{} denotes expectation.
Consider (y_1,y_2) are discrete and have a joint distribution such that
the following (y_1,y_2) pairs are equally likely:
(0,1),(0,1),(1,0),(1,0). It is easy to verify that they are
uncorrelated. But if we choose h_1 and h_2 to be the squared function,
then the above property, M, is violated. Since independence implies M
holds for all functions, and we have found a function for which it does
not hold, y_1 and y_2 cannot be independent.
Since the logic can be confusing, here it is in detail:
Independent => M for all h_1, h_2
therefore
not(M for all h_1,h_2) => not(Independent)
therefore
there exists an h_1, h_2 for which M not true => not(Independent)
It is also easy to see intuitively that the above counterexample works:
the marginalised pdf of y_1 is that it takes the values {1,0,1} with
probabilities {1/4, 1/2, 1/4}. But if we know that y_2 is 1, then that
constrains y_1 to be zero. So knowing y_2 has changed our knowledge of
y_1.
Another counterexample:
Let s and a be discrete random variables which take values 1 and 1
with 50% probability each.
Let x take the value of a if s=1, otherwise zero. Now x and s are clearly
uncorrelated, but are not independent since knowing s determines the pdf
of x.

This website uses no cookies. This page was last modified 20130512 10:17
by .

